Today I've been reading about a girl named Victoria Climbie. She was born near the Ivory Coast of Africa. When she was six years old, her mother's aunt showed up at their home and told her mother that she wanted to take one of the six children to France to educate him or her. Victoria's mother thought this was a fab opportunity for her daughter, even though apparently she had really only seen this woman a few times before in her life.
Victoria and the aunt went to France, getting through immigration by saying that Victoria was the aunt's daughter. They stayed for a few months, then went to the UK. Perhaps they left because the French government was investigating the aunt's claims for welfare-like benefits. When they arrived in the UK, the aunt went to the local benefits offices to register herself and her "daughter." Over the next couple of years, the aunt found a new boyfriend, and the aunt and Victoria moved into his studio apartment. Victoria wet her bed regularly, perhaps because her aunt scolded her and physically abused her on a regular basis.
By the time Victoria was eight years old (in 2000), she was forced to sleep in the bathtub, often in a garbage bag, because of her incontinence problem. She died that year, and when she was examined after her death, doctors found 128 injuries. She never went to school in France or the UK.
This case was a really big deal here in the UK, in terms of what social services should be doing for children. A social worker who had been assigned to her case later lost her license to do social work. This year, she was reinstated with her license, but expects that she will never practice social work again. Many people here are upset that her license was reinstated, because they think someone needs to be punished for Victoria's death.
The social worker in question was at junior level at her agency. She had only been working as a social worker for a year and a half. Her office had given her double the caseload a social worker in her position should have. During the time she was assigned to Victoria's case, she took the case to three of her managers, all of whom told her there were no problems and she should close the case.
I agree that some malpractice occurred in this event. I think it's been a positive step that the government has taken measures to address this issue, and that more attention needs to be paid to child abuse issues. I also think that social work is not an easy job. It doesn't pay well, it can be dangerous, and social workers often face obstacles they're not trained to deal with. It is not a glamorous profession, and most people do not grow up wanting to be social workers.
Victoria's mother was in the UK earlier this year. She made a public statement that the UK social services had let her down, and that she was shocked that terrible things were still happening to children. I have much sympathy for this woman. It would be awful to believe that you were sending your child off for a better life and then be faced with what happened. But I also think she deserves some responsibility for sending her daughter to another country with someone she didn't know well, and for not keeping in close contact with the aunt and her daughter for the next few years.
Much of the media I read about child protective services today blame the state of social services, saying they had a duty to protect our children. Fair enough. That's their job. But it is the job of parents to protect their children, as well.
And this leaves me wondering whether the target of the social services protection is focused properly. A lot of parents seem to have problems taking care of their children, and many directly abuse them. I know we can't have laws about who can have children, but can we offer more support to parents? Can there be classes or support groups about what to do when you feel frustrated with your kids? How to deal with anger better? Could some of the money targeted for welfare and social services go toward training on how to be a better parent to your children? Could high schools offer this type of class? Could obstetricians recommend such classes to expectant parents?
I know there's no easy answer. But there's so much talk about how abortion and even birth control is such a problem, and so little effort is made to help new parents deal with the challenge of having children--wanted or unwanted. Raising kids is not inherent for many people. In the end, the responsibility of caring for children should begin with the people who decide to bring them into this world--their parents.